Wonderstruck DVD review - Todd Haynes' temporal displacement leaves him at a loss
Share This Article:
Verdict: The Carol director flounders in this adaptation from the writer of Hugo. In Todd Haynes’ previous film, Carol (2015), cinematic ‘purity’ was woven into the film’s existence. Shot on film (Super 16 mm, no less), it brought about tones of both forgotten home movies and Hollywood romance, as much a love story between Haynes and cinema as it was Therese and Carol in the film. Yet, that purity is also there to reflect the hegemony of America’s nuclear family in the 1950s, which Therese and Carol directly contradict with their romance. For much of the film, because of the earnestness of the two characters trying to control their urges, their attraction to each other is unspoken – an undertone. Going back and examining Carol gives us an understanding of why Wonderstruck fails. Here, in the interwoven stories of two societally displaced children 50 years apart, its earnestness is a pitfall. Haynes equates simplicity in storytelling to a fable, and might have succeeded in doing so if he weren’t so obtuse about the details of the film’s narrative.
- Article continues below...
- More stories you may like...
- Red Joan review - a fascinating true story that falls a little flat
- The best rom-coms on Netflix right now
- Cannes 2019: 10 films to look out for
You might also like...
People who read this also read...
CONTRIBUTOR OF THE MONTH